Paper Requirement for Alvin H. Sample
- Paper: Alvin H. Sample and Mitchell Wand, "P
is unequal to NP", JACM 35:1 (2004), 1-56.
- Description: This paper proved that P was
unequal to NP by appeal to the Schermerhorn-Matterhorn-Bassetthorn
Counting Lemma and the Rumpelmyer-Drosselmeier-Oscarmeyer Canine
Heating Algorithm. It was rejected by STOC, ICFP, and POPL before
being accepted by JACM and published in a special issue.
- Acceptance rate: the three conferences have
acceptance rates around 20%, so we weren't too surprised by the
rejection. The acceptance rate for JACM is unknown.
- Student's contribution to paper: Alvin did the
whole thing by himself. I corrected a few typos and reminded him that
contextual equivalence for call-by-value was incomparable to that for
call-by-name.
- URL for paper: [put link here, I've run out
of jokes]
- Why should this paper be accepted as qualifying the
paper requirement: Nobody cares about this stuff, but it
clearly demonstrates that Alvin can undertake academic research.